May 16th, 2016
Warning: Inevitable Spoilers Below
So, let me state up front that I unambiguously enjoyed Captain America: Civil War. It’s easily the best Marvel film since Guardians of the Galaxy, and a whole lot more engaging than Age of Ultron. It was great to see Black Panther on the big screen, and I thought Chadwick Boseman nailed his performance. Tom Holland’s very traditional Spider-Man was a complete success, vastly superior to Andrew Garfield’s emo rendering of the character. The film had a ton of things to love, including probably the best live-action superhero fight scene of all time.
My issues with it aren’t about its entertainment value, which is very high, but its politics, which are convoluted. I can only imagine how difficult a task it must to tell a story about preserving individual liberty while protecting larger, social interests without occupying positions established by contemporary American politics. To engage with these issues, you have to either occupy an existing political ground, stake out new territory, or demonstrate that the binary is false in the first place. Or, alternatively, you can try to ignore the questions you, yourself, raise, which is what this film ends up doing.
In the original Civil War crossover event in Marvel comics, on which the movie is based, Iron Man is right to worry about the public’s anxiety about unsupervised superheroes. These superheroes are more plentiful, public, and varied in their sense of civic duty than superheroes in the films. In the comics, Captain America’s assertion that heroes have to be free to follow their own moral compasses is validated when the agency overseeing heroes, S.H.I.E.L.D. adopts a merciless policy of capturing and imprisoning heroes who wish only to be free to do good.
In the Marvel Cinematic Universe, however, there is less time and space to lead up to this conflict. The films simply can’t deploy as many characters, or as much context, as the comic book universe had at its disposal. The comics offered a story about the public being genuinely and justifiably worried about a massive population of superheroes, some of whom are drunk on their own power. People die because no one is making sure superheroes use their abilities responsibly. In the comics, Captain America is 100% right – and so is Iron Man. Superheroes are unambiguously out of control, and need to be reined in. Government oversight turns out to be dangerous and corrupt, vulnerable to the same super-villainy that that heroes have been fighting for decades.
A complex political situation in which there are no easy answers? Well-meaning, thoughtful characters having to choose between two necessarily flawed extremes? Sign me up. Sadly, the movie doesn’t seem up to the task, and instead offers a story about a public outraged because the Avengers could not save absolutely everyone while saving the planet. In the cinematic universe, innocent people die not because of superhero recklessness but because superheroes simply lack the means or the power to save everyone.
The end result is that the film’s argument against government oversight ends up looking a lot like American conservative arguments in favor of individual liberty. It’s important to keep in mind that the very notion that there necessarily must be a conflict between individual liberties and government oversight is, in itself, a conservative, position. That bias is the dominant theme in Captain America: Civil War. In fact, Iron Man’s case for government oversight ends up demonstrating the “wisdom” of the American right’s party line. This view promotes the notion that it’s wrong to place individual liberty in the hands of bureaucrats, because these government functionaries are invariably either ignorant about real world conditions or too invested in their own agenda’s to care much about how policies affect people. To bolster these arguments, the right often deploy anecdotes about wronged individuals (c.f. specific civilians killed when the Avengers fight bad guys) while completely ignoring the much broader benefits of government intervention in various social or political spheres (c.f. Avengers saving everyone except the few individuals who slip through the cracks).
Now, I’m biased. I’d argue that the right, when promoting individual liberties, is often really looking to protect corporate liberties or the rights of the wealthy. The left, I believe, promotes individual liberties through advocating for civil, voting, and human rights, and sees government oversight as the best means of insuring those rights are protected. The left would argue that in real life, and as a matter of practical experience, government oversight and individual liberty need not be at odds. They can be balanced for maximum benefit to both individuals and society as a whole. The right would argue that balance is impossible and therefore you must choose one side or the other.
This is the line taken by Captain America: Civil War, which never attempts to find a balanced solution to this global non-problem. Instead, the deployment of the Avengers is to be at the discretion of the United Nations. It seems to me foolish and impractical to place global security, or the response to dangers that may be sudden and immediate, in the hands of a bunch of bickering bureaucrats. You can already see the nuclear bombs going off while diplomats shout at one another. Thus government control because a simple straw man, ready to be knocked down.
The filmmakers are clearly smart enough to understand that they’ve wandered into an ideological mess, and seem desperate to avoid asking too many challenging questions. That’s too bad, since, having brought up the subject in the first place, there’s some great material they could have used to render these positions more complex. Captain America squared off against the Nazis, and he’s seen what happens when governments become too powerful. Iron Man ought to know something about superheroes acting recklessly. Ultron, whom the Avengers prevented from destroying life on earth, was Tony Stark’s creation in the first place.
These guys have real skin in the game, but the film seems reluctant to do more than keep these issues simmering beneath the surface. Instead, arguments are petty and not terribly ideological. Captain America supports individual liberties because he wants to save his friend. Tony Stark favors government oversight because he wants to go along to get along. The original comic book universe Civil War event raised a lot of interesting questions about personal liberty and public responsibility. It managed to avoid deflect necessary comparison by real-world politics by making the politics of its story unique and specific to the Marvel Universe. The movie, however, skirts the same issues, dealing with them in such a cursory manner that comparisons to contemporary American politics are inevitable and unsatisfying.
Instead of a complex political story, the film tells a great story about characters (see this article for some insight into Tony Stark in particular), which I applaud. Action movies are too often light on complex character development. Age of Ultron, in my opinion, either ignored, or mishandled, its characters, but Captain America: Civil War moves many of the same characters forward in subtle and fascinating ways. I do think it’s unfortunate that a movie that seems poised to ask difficult political questions ends up encouraging viewers to forget it ever raised the subject . These issues would have only made the character development stronger and more compelling. The end result of its treatment of its political themes that the film presents a view of the struggle between the state and the individual that is biased, and in my (admittedly biased) opinion, wrong.
September 4th, 2015
Volume 1 of the Randoms trilogy.
“RANDOMS by David Liss is a Smart Sci-Fi Adventure for the Young and Young At Heart!” — SF Signal
“Liss strikes cosmic gold in this addictive space saga with solid writing, excellent storytelling and pacing, and imaginative world building. Randoms is an exhilarating read. – Booklist: starred review
March 15th, 2015
What is going on in 2015? Behold!
I’ll be updating more regularly come this summer, but in the meantime, here is a quick run-down of my publications for the year. There are a few more surprises in the works, but this is everything I am physical, and legally, able to talk about at this precise moment.
May 7th, 2014
BUY THIS NOW!
Angelica Tomorrow is my first creator-owned comic. Artist Allen Byrns and I created this story and we own it, and now we want you to read it. So go do that. It only costs $1.99 so the risk to your happiness is minimal. Right now the first issue is available digitally from Comixology. When the six-issue run is finished, we’ll be putting out a trade paperback.
It’s a classic tale of teenage, paraplegic alcoholic meets amnesiac cyborg assassin! Three years ago, George Williams life changed forever when a car accident left him paralyzed below the waist. Now, everything will change again after a nighttime encounter with deadly stranger who possesses incredible powers she cannot recall or understand. Only George knows that beneath the shell of the sweet and naïve girl lies a monster, but which is the real Angelica, and how long can George keep the killer hidden way? Pursued by ruthless spies, and a police officer seeking revenge, George and Angelica will find themselves tested in ways they never imagined.
I’m in the process of getting doing some updating on the web page so if you want information on my next novel, The Day of Atonement, which will be out in September, click here.
May 6th, 2014
In 1745 the Portuguese Inquisition came for Sebastião Raposa’s parents. While his mother and father died in the prisons beneath the Palace of the Inquisition, young Sebastião was smuggled out of Portugal. Now, ten years later, he returns to the city he hates, disguised as an English merchant, with one purpose in mind: find the priest who destroyed his parents and exact vengeance. But Sebastian Foxx will learn that Lisbon is no less treacherous than when he left, and soon he is embroiled in schemes plotted by friends and enemies alike — and it will become increasingly difficult to tell the difference.
Pre-order now. It’s what the cool kids are doing.
July 25th, 2011
Now in Paperback!
Tremendously appealing characters . . . a thoroughly enjoyable, satisfying read.”—Deborah Harkness, author of A Discovery of Witches
Lucy Derrick is a young woman of good breeding and poor finances. After the death of her beloved father, she is forced to maintain a shabby dignity as the unwanted boarder of her tyrannical uncle, fending off marriage to a local mill owner. But just as she is on the cusp of accepting a life of misery, events take a stunning turn when a handsome stranger—the poet and notorious rake Lord Byron—arrives at her house, stricken by what seems to be a curse, and with a cryptic message for Lucy. Suddenly her unfortunate circumstances are transformed in ways at once astonishing and seemingly impossible.
With the world undergoing an industrial transformation, and with England on the cusp of revolution, Lucy is drawn into a dangerous conspiracy in which her life, and her country’s future, are in the balance. Inexplicably finding herself at the center of cataclysmic events, Lucy is awakened to a world once unknown to her: where magic and mortals collide, and the forces of ancient nature and modern progress are at war for the soul of England . . . and the world. The key to victory may be connected to a cryptic volume whose powers of enchantment are unbounded. Now, challenged by ruthless enemies with ancient powers at their command, Lucy must harness newfound mystical skills to prevent catastrophe and preserve humanity’s future. And enthralled by two exceptional men with designs on her heart, she must master her own desires to claim the destiny she deserves.
June 1st, 2011
We’ve got an action-packed summer and autumn planned for you over here at davidliss.com, so here’s a handy score card to help you keep track of onslaught of David Liss mayhem.
Mystery Men #1 – #2
The first two issues of this five-part miniseries will ship in June. Telling, for the first time, the story of Marvel’s earliest generation of costumed vigilantes in New York, this is a dark, pulp-era mystery set firmly within – but requiring no previous knowledge of – the Marvel U. 1932, guys in cool hats, a dead Broadway starlet, an insidious plot, evil capitalists, and a dark plot against the country. Five heroes will rise to protect America in its darkest hour. This is a perfect series to follow for readers who have been interested in my comics but haven’t known where to jump in. This preview will give you a good sense of Patrick Zircher’s amazing art.
Black Panther: The Man Without Fear #519 – #520
Storm Hunter! A two-part, self contained story with both issues shipping this month. It’s the T’Challa, the most dangerous man alive vs. Kraven, the deadliest hunter in the Marvel U. Plus Storm. A great place to jump into the unfolding Black Panther saga. Very cool art by Jefte Palo, which you can see here.
Black Panther: The Man Without Fear #521
The events of marvel’s big summer event, Fear Itself, catch up with Black Panther as a 3-part story begins in which we introduce the American Panther. Marvel has teased this storyline, but we’ve said very little. You’ll have to pick up the issue to learn more, though you can take a look at this teaser article if you enjoy, you know, being teased.
Mystery Men #3
The mystery continues!
Black Panther: The Man Without Fear Urban Jungle
If you missed our first arc of Black Panther, you can pick up this trade paperback which collects the first six issues. It makes for great summer reading.
The Twelfth Enchantment
My new novel! Set during the Regency and the Luddite Uprising, the first organized resistance to the industrial revolution. Think Jane Austen meets urban fantasy. Lucy Derrick, an impoverished woman on the cusp of a disastrous marriage is drawn into a mysterious plot in which new technology wars with ancient knowledge. Lord Byron, William Blake and Mansfield Park’s Mary Crawford! I had a blast writing this one.
Black Panther: The Man Without Fear #522
Our Fear Itself and American Panther story continues.
Mystery Men #4
The mystery continues again!
Black Panther: The Man Without Fear #523
The conclusion of our Fear Itself tie-in.
Mystery Men #5
The saga comes to a thrilling conclusion.
An anthology of stories about (non-vampire or zombie) monsters, told from their perspective. My story, “The Awkward Age,” is about a sexy ghoul. This is of particular interest to those who liked my story, “What Masie Knew,” which appeared in Chris’s anthology, The New Dead.
Assassins: Sword of the Apocalypse
My second full-lenth book of the year! This is an illustrated novel that is being published by comics indie, Radical. It’s the Third Crusade and an ancient evil brings together an unlikely band of heroes: King Richard the Lionheart, Saladin, Robert of Locksley (the future Robin Hood), Temujin (the future Genghis Khan), Morgiana (of the Ali Baba story) and Moses Maimonides. This is fun historical fantasy with amazing art.
I can’t tell you exactly what we’re doing this month because it has not yet been announced, but I’m very proud of this script, and I think you guys are going to dig this.
May 12th, 2011
We definitely have an exciting summer in the works for you over here at davidliss.com. Not only has the publication date of my next novel, The Twelfth Enchantment, been moved up to August 9th, but I’ve got a new project on tap from Marvel which weds comics with historical fiction.
Mystery Men, which debuts on June 8th, is a 5-part miniseries set in New York in the early 1930s.
This is a new chapter in the history of the Marvel Universe, and tells the story of the first generation of urban vigilantes to put on costumes and fight crime. Five all new, all cool pulp-style heroes. A murdered starlet. A dark conspiracy. Evil capitalists and a plot to do terrible things. Amazing art by Patrick Zircher. You can read an 8-page preview right now, and I’ll remind you when this bad boy hits the stands.
April 25th, 2011
Exciting developments are afoot over here at Davidliss.com. The biggest news is that the title of my next novel has been changed from The Darkening Green to The Twelfth Enchantment. I argued for Revenge of the Jedi, but no one listened to me. It also looks like the publication date has been moved up to August. I will post more details, including tour dates, when they become available.
This cover art is final, or near final, or not final. I’m not sure which. But I think it’s final, so let’s pretend that it is. Let me know what you think.
March 1st, 2011
In the year 2000, while Random House was busy promoting my first novel, A Conspiracy of Paper, as the historical novel of the season, Grove was promoting The Dress Lodger by Sheri Holman in precisely the same way. Consequently, I hated Sheri Holman’s guts. I began reading her reviews and interviews with considerable malice. I bought her book to see how bad it was, and I was furious that not only was it not bad, it was really, really great. I think we can all agree that writing a great book that competes with my novel is rude. And then there was that saucy author photo, which made me hate her even more.
It turned out that on my first publicity tour, she and I were to appear at the same book-and-author brunch in Toronto, and I was getting all worked up to hate her guts in person. Then we were seated next to each other and became friends over the course of about 45 seconds. It didn’t hurt that she’d hated my guts from afar too. We’ve been friends since, and I’ve been in awe of her books since. She’s my pal, so I don’t have to resent her awesomeness.
Sheri’s work is always accomplished, smart, engaging, emotionally disarming, and completely absorbing, but her new book, Witches on the Road Tonight, is impressive by even her standards. This is a thoughtful meditation on the legacy of fear and family dysfunction, but it is also a page-turner about disturbed and disturbing characters who (hooray!) often behave horribly, but whose bad behavior is affecting human. Click on the pretty book cover for more info. Then buy it or face my wrath.